PCDVD數位科技討論區

PCDVD數位科技討論區 (https://www.pcdvd.com.tw/index.php)
-   七嘴八舌異言堂 (https://www.pcdvd.com.tw/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   以色列空襲伊朗成效差 多層防空系統展現實力 (https://www.pcdvd.com.tw/showthread.php?t=1210685)

ankk 2024-11-02 11:01 AM

引用:
作者二手舊貨商
前面的作者[acmilan],引用的是[https://www.chinatimes.com]的文章,巷子內的都知道,[chinatime]是怎樣的文章
1.親共的媒體
2.總是講俄爹多強大、祖國多偉大、常常喊的就是
A.以色列慘了
B.日本完了
C.美國輸了
[美急著運THAAD反導系統給以色列就證明了鐵穹和愛國者防空飛彈完全對付不了伊朗的彈道飛彈...]
不是以色列的鐵芎、箭式、大衛投石索系統不好,而是伊朗一次發射的量太大,有些漏網之魚。薩德的優勢是偵測距離更遠、更精準,並且以色列還要同時面對伊朗、哈瑪斯、真主黨、敘利亞的武裝組織所有四面八方發射過來的飛彈。這不是容易的事。
鐵芎太好用了,連美軍都向以色列購買,這是不爭的事實,也已經是新聞早就報導過的舊聞了。
美國在南韓部屬薩德,誰跳腳啊?中共跳腳。因為一套薩德的監控就非常有效了。


中時引用的也是外國媒體耶

Iran counters Israel attacks with 100km-range air defense missiles

https://bulgarianmilitary.com/2024/...fense-missiles/

In a dramatic escalation of tensions, Iranian air defense units successfully intercepted several missiles launched by Israel during the early hours of October 26. This response came shortly after Israeli forces executed a series of missile strikes targeting the Iranian capital, Tehran. While the scale of the assault was relatively small, preliminary reports indicate that Iranian forces effectively neutralized all incoming threats.

Conflicting accounts have emerged regarding the number of waves in which Israel launched its attacks. While Western and Israeli sources differ, Iranian reports suggest multiple waves were involved. Israel’s strategy relied on long-range air-launched missiles, fired from positions well outside Iranian airspace, minimizing the risk to its aircraft.

Hours prior to the Israeli operation, Russian officials alerted Iran to the impending strikes, sharing intelligence about potential targets and Israeli maneuvers, according to sources who spoke with Sky News Arabia. This collaboration underscores Russia’s commitment to maintaining regional stability and aiding Iran in preparing its defenses. Despite sustaining damage to military installations in Tehran, Khuzestan, and Ilam provinces—resulting in the tragic loss of two Iranian soldiers—Iranian authorities reported that their air defenses intercepted many of the attacking missiles.

According to Axios, Israel directly communicated with Iran through intermediaries before the strikes, urging restraint and warning of a stronger retaliation if civilian casualties occurred. On October 25, Dutch Foreign Minister Kaspar Veldkamp also called for de-escalation during a conversation with his Iranian counterpart. The following day, the Israeli Defense Forces declared the successful completion of their air operation, which targeted air defense systems and missile production facilities while intentionally avoiding nuclear and oil infrastructure to focus solely on military objectives.

Iran condemned the Israeli strikes as a breach of international law, asserting its right to self-defense under Article 51 of the United Nations Charter. Whether Iran will retaliate remains uncertain; sources from Sky News Arabia indicate that Iran signaled, through intermediaries, a decision to refrain from immediate retaliation, while reports from Tasnim suggest that Tehran is ready to respond and cautioned that Israel would face a proportional counteraction.

Simultaneously, the United States urged Iran to halt its aggressive actions, warning that continued hostilities could lead to American support for Israel’s defense and potential consequences if tensions escalate further.

Israel’s strategy mirrors past operations against Syrian targets, particularly following the downing of an Israeli F-16I by a Syrian S-200 missile in 2018. Leaked U.S. intelligence also suggests that Israel may be contemplating the use of long-range air-launched ballistic missiles against Iranian positions.

In response to the initial wave of attacks, Iranian forces deployed medium-range surface-to-air missiles [SAMs] to counter the Israeli missiles. For subsequent strikes, Iran utilized long-range defense systems capable of intercepting missiles from distances exceeding 100 kilometers—an important advancement.

Among Iran’s air defense arsenal are upgraded Russian-made S-300PMU-2 systems, known for their advanced interception capabilities. While the standard 48N6E2 missiles have a range of 200 kilometers, these systems are reportedly compatible with the more advanced 48N6DM missiles, which boast interception ranges of up to 250 kilometers and are designed to counter hypersonic threats.

Iran acquired these upgraded S-300 missiles in 2020, speculated to include the 48N6DM variant, which has successfully been tested by China against targets traveling faster than Mach 8 at a range of 250 kilometers—outperforming Israel’s air-launched missile technology.

In addition to the S-300 systems, Iran has a diverse array of long-range air defense capabilities. Its Soviet-era S-200D system, dating back to the 1990s, remains one of the longest-ranged options, capable of engaging targets at distances up to 300 kilometers. Although modernized for enhanced mobility, the S-200 is primarily designed to defend against larger threats like ballistic missiles rather than smaller aerial targets.

Iran’s most advanced domestically developed air defense system, the Bavar-373, reportedly reached an impressive range of 300 kilometers as of April, following the integration of the new Sayyad-4B missile. This system may have played a critical role in recent interceptions. Another homegrown system, the Khordad 15, offers a lighter alternative to the Bavar-373, with an engagement range exceeding 100 kilometers, although details about its deployment remain limited.

Iran’s reliance on ground-based air defenses is largely attributed to its constrained inventory of modern fighter aircraft. This multi-layered defense network poses a significant challenge to Israel and its allies, reinforcing Iran’s extensive missile deterrent strategy. The sophisticated integration of these ground defenses with cutting-edge electronic warfare and radar systems further bolsters Iran’s defensive posture in the region.

healthfirst. 2024-11-02 11:09 AM

有看到自媒體說以色列戰機奔襲1000公里
甚至飛過伊朗首都
伊朗防空都沒啥反應

?
公開資料都查得到
以色列戰機完全沒靠近過伊朗
有些自媒體整天胡說八道
把觀眾當白痴耍.......

老老濕 2024-11-02 04:01 PM

伊朗的火箭燃料工廠
距離邊界600km以上

如過以色列不飛進伊朗領空
要如何打中目標

簡單思考
就算以軍戰機飛入他國領空.也不可能會承認

就如同當年
以色列派F-16C去炸毀伊拉克核武工廠一樣

等到爆炸後
海珊才發現
自家的核武工廠起火燃燒

smoguli 2024-11-02 05:37 PM

洗地工只會盲吹 , 不知道以色列納粹有藍麻雀也很正常.......
:p

另外 , 因為射向德黑蘭的幾枚飛彈都被攔截或提早墜毀沒落在附近 , 所以這也是為什麼相關影片都沒有飛彈飛過的畫面 , 也沒有飛彈爆炸的聲響
:flash:

老老濕 2024-11-02 06:08 PM

以軍還發射
低成本誘餌飛彈

在烏克蘭戰場上
吸引俄軍高價S400飛彈來攔截

至於伊朗只有古老的S300飛彈
用電子干擾
就可以讓伊朗雷達白茫茫

美國有整套的S300飛彈系統
要干擾一點不困難

fantasyxxx 2024-11-02 09:35 PM

引用:
作者healthfirst.
沒有閉關鎖國
沒有網路長城
卻依然可以形成資訊封閉的義和團
真的很佩服 :cool:

就是說呀,
寧願相信親共媒體和對岸有心人仕製造的假新聞,
也不願相信其他的主流媒體 :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

fantasyxxx 2024-11-02 09:43 PM

引用:
作者ankk
中時引用的也是外國媒體耶

Iran counters Israel attacks with 100km-range air defense missiles

https://bulgarianmilitary.com/2024/...fense-missiles/

In a dramatic escalation of tensions, Iranian air defense units successfully intercepted several missiles launched by Israel during the early hours of October 26. This response came shortly after Israeli forces executed a series of missile strikes targeting the Iranian capital, Tehran. While the scale of the assault was relatively small, preliminary reports indicate that Iranian forces effectively neutralized all incoming threats.

Conflicting accounts have emerged regarding the number of waves in which Israel launched its attacks. ...

這是保加利亞軍事網 :ase
而且原文報導較為中性,
意思是說伊朗和以色列對戰果的評估各說各話,
但中時卻斷章取義只說伊朗攔截成功、沒受到重大損失 :laugh:

fantasyxxx 2024-11-02 10:05 PM

打你就像打條狗,以軍戰機2000公里奔襲伊朗,3小時速通德黑蘭!,老神棍呼吁克制 | 說真話的徐某人
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-eShvsZTf4c

上面的影片參考就好,
但有件事實無法辨駁
即然攔截率高,那應該會發現很多被打下來的導彈殘骸,
伊朗神棍政府也一定會拿出來大肆宣揚才對
哈米尼也一直等到今天才講說要報復 :laugh:

只是我猜他可能比較擔心幾天後的美國大選結果,
川普當選之後說不定會授權以色列打掉伊朗的核設施 :ase
所以不敢有太大動作

fantasyxxx 2024-11-02 10:10 PM

引用:
作者healthfirst.
有看到自媒體說以色列戰機奔襲1000公里
甚至飛過伊朗首都
伊朗防空都沒啥反應

?
公開資料都查得到
以色列戰機完全沒靠近過伊朗
有些自媒體整天胡說八道
把觀眾當白痴耍.......

伊朗自己發出防空砲朝天空發射的影片 :ase

真象 2024-11-02 11:00 PM

引用:
作者二手舊貨商
1.難民轟炸 - 因為裡面窩藏哈瑪斯恐怖份子
2.對醫院轟炸 - 因為醫院底下就是哈瑪斯的隧道
3.對己申報的救援團體轟炸暗殺 - 因為聯合國的維和部隊事實上成了哈瑪斯、真主黨的掩護者
4.在民用產品裡設置炸彈進行無差別攻擊 - 因為真主黨已經預謀設定好攻擊以色列的日期與時間,所以以色列先下手
5.對巴勒斯坦農田投放除草劑 - 因為哈瑪斯要縱火燒到以色列國境之內


那巴勒斯坦對以色列攻擊也可以用全民皆兵,所以沒有一個以色列人是無辜的,而猶太人都是自動取得以色列的國藉,所以海外的巴勒斯坦人都可以對猶太人攻擊了,因為他們是屠夫。

別為以色列說話,他們就是恐佈份子的國度


所有的時間均為GMT +8。 現在的時間是02:56 AM.

vBulletin Version 3.0.1
powered_by_vbulletin 2024。